Category Archives: Musings & News

Snowy Owl? Or Plastic Bag?

Is that a snowy owl? Franklin County, PA 12 Jan 2014 (photo by Nancy Magnusson via Flickr Creative Commons license)

23 January 2025

Those who ventured out in this week’s bitter cold hoped to see birds from the far north who had just arrived on the wind. The typical way to find them is to drive past frozen fields watching for movement and scanning for anything that looks like a bird.

What’s that white lump in the field? Is it a snowy owl? Or a plastic bag?

Eleven years ago the winter of 2013-2014 was extremely cold and there was a huge irruption of snowy owls in the Northeast and Great Lakes. People photographed all of them, even the distant ones, to document them in eBird.

At top: Is that a plastic bag on that patch of snow? Below: Are there plastic bags or snowy owls in this photo? And how many?

Where’s the snowy owl? There are 3 in Jackson County, MI on 26 Dec 2013 (photo by Don Henise via Flickr Creative Commons license)

Is there a snowy owl in this picture?

Where’s the snowy owl in this picture? West Dennis Beach, Cape Cod, 17 Jan 2014 (photo by On The Wander via Flickr Creative Commons license)

Answer: All three photos have a snowy owls in them. The middle photo has 3 along the ridge top.

This winter we have not seen a big influx of snowy owls into Pennsylvania though there have been a couple of sightings.

screenshot of snowy owl sightings in the northeastern US in Jan 2025 (eBird species map as of 23 Jan 2025)

Recently there’s a snowy owl near Grantsville, Maryland which is often photographed from afar. A white lump?

If you’ve ever looked for a snowy owl and found a plastic bag you’ll enjoy the story and photos at The Search for Snowy Owls by Friends of the Fox River in Elgin, Illinois.

Cats, Cows and Cardinals: More Info on Bird Flu

13 January 2025

After hundreds of snow geese died in eastern Pennsylvania on New Years Day of suspected avian influenza, there has been more attention on H5N1 in PA. The current focus is on the danger to domestic poultry and how we can avoid catching it ourselves from live or dead birds. Here are three avian flu topics you may not have heard about.

Cats

Did you know that cats and dogs can catch H5N1 by contact with dead or sick birds or their droppings? If your cat or dog mouths or eats a bird with avian influenza, he can catch the virus.

Cats like to drink milk and on dairy farms they drink it before it’s pasteurized. That’s how we found out it’s possible to catch bird flu from raw milk. According to Your Local Epidemiologist, “Fifty percent of cats that drink raw milk died.”

Update on 17 January 2025: Veterinarians recently discovered that cats also can catch H5N1 from raw pet food and it is just as deadly as drinking infected raw milk — 50% die. Two brands have been recalled. See: Cat deaths linked to bird flu-contaminated raw pet food, sparking voluntary recall.

Cows

Farm cats gave us the clue that infected dairy cows express the virus in their milk. The fact that cows caught bird flu was a surprise itself. Pigs are the usual domestic mammal pathway but last year H5N1 jumped from poultry to cows and then mutated to spread cow-to-cow.

Cardinals … and backyard birds

The wild birds that catch H5N1 avian influenza are waterfowl (ducks, geese), shorebirds, wild poultry (turkeys, grouse) and the birds that eat them: raptors (hawks, eagles, falcons) and scavengers (crows, gulls, vultures). Backyard birds are not susceptible. Your Local Epidemiologist explains:

What about bird feeders? Birds that gather at feeders (like cardinals, sparrows, and bluebirds) do not typically carry H5N1. The USDA does not recommend removing backyard bird feeders for H5N1 prevention unless you also care for poultry. The less contact between wild birds and poultry (by removing sources of food, water, and shelter), the better.

YLe: H5N1 Update – January 7

The PA Game Commission agrees that backyard birds are not susceptible and adds that we should always keep our feeders clean to stop the spread of disease.

Clean your feeders every couple of weeks. Wild Birds Unlimited tells you how at Bird Feeder Cleaning & Care, including a video.

And … “If you notice multiple sick or dead birds over a short period of time, you should strongly consider leaving feeders down and baths empty to not make any potential outbreak worse.”

For more practical information on H5N1 and other infectious diseases follow Your Local Epidemiologist on Substack.

(photos from Wikimedia Commons at these links: cat, cows, cardinal)

Descendants of The Terror Birds

Illustration of a Terror Bird, Titanis walleri (image from Wikimedia Commons)

12 January 2025

Today we live among the descendants of the Terror Birds. Who were they? And who are they now?

Terror Birds (Phorusrhacids) were a genus of large, flightless, carnivorous birds that thrived in South America from 43 million to 100,000 years ago. Wikipedia describes them as “among the largest apex predators in South America during the Cenozoic era.” 

As you can see from this diagram the largest of them could easily have eaten a human and, because Homo sapiens evolved around 300,000 years ago, we were on Earth before they went extinct. We would have been in danger but we were in Africa, separated by an ocean from these terrifying ancestors of modern birds.

Height comparison of four Terror Birds (illustration from Wikimedia Commons, includes accuracy note)

DNA studies in 2024 refined the phylogenetic supertree of birds placing Terror Birds as ancestors in the clade Australaves, the group that evolved in South America and Australia. Click on the image below to see a larger version of the diagram.

Phylogenetic supertree by Stiller, J., Feng, S., Chowdhury, AA. et al. Complexity of avian evolution revealed by family-level genomes. Nature 629, 851–860 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-07323-1

Because the diagram has hundreds of tiny details I’ve hand-drawn the Terror Bird section starting with their nearest living relative, the seriema. Notice who else is descended from the Terror Birds!

Australaves descended from the Terror Birds, drawn by Kate St. John, derived fromphylogenetic supertree by Stiller, J., Feng, S., Chowdhury, AA. et al. Complexity of avian evolution revealed by family-level genomes. Nature 629, 851–860 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-07323-1

Let’s take a photographic journey through the tree.

First come the seriemas, who stand alone without other relatives. These South American birds have a lifestyle and appearance similar to the secretarybird of Africa, though they are not related. Here a red-legged seriema (Cariama cristata) kills a snake.

Red-legged seriema with snake (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

Then come falcons. Interestingly, everything else is descended from them including …

Peregrine falcon, Stellar, in Youngstown, Ohio, approx 2008 (photo by Chad+Chris Saladin)

parrots

Hyacinth macaw (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

New Zealand wrens, who stand alone without other relatives …

South Island wren, New Zealand (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

flycatchers

Olive-sided flycatcher (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

… and all the other songbirds.

Northern cardinal in winter (photo by Steve Gosser)

“Terror Birds” we know today are far less terrifying. 🙂

They’ve Changed Because of Us

African elephants with and without tusks (photos from Wikimedia Commons)

7 January 2025

We’ve often heard and seen how species change their behavior because of humans. Birds now spend the winter near us because of our bird feeders. Mammals originally fled cities, then moved back into them (deer and raccoons). But an article in the Guardian caught my attention when it described physical changes in animals’ bodies wrought by human pressure. Here are two examples.

African elephants without tusks

During the Mozambican civil war, heavy poaching by fighters meant that African savannah elephant numbers plunged by more than 90% in Gorongosa national park. With populations now in recovery and representing one of the most important examples of global restoration, many of the female elephants have no tusks – a consequence of tuskless elephants being less likely to be targeted by poachers, say researchers. The same change has also been recorded in Tanzania.

The Guardian: Shrinking trees and tuskless elephants: the strange ways species are adapting to humans

The map shows where this has happened: Tanzania (north) and Mozambique (southern half of red area).

Map of Mozambique and Tanzania in Africa (merg of two maps from Wikimedia Commons)
Shrinking mahogany trees

Mahogany trees, native to Central and South America, have disappeared from large parts of their historic range. Two of the three species are listed as Endangered yet some individuals survive by adapting. Because the largest trees are always cut down, only the shrubby ones survive and they’re the ones that reproduce. As a result, mahogany trees have shrunk in the wild.

Mahogany trees have become shrubby in the wild (photos from Wikimedia Commons)

Here’s how human pressure changed the range of Endangered big-leaf mahogany (Swietenia macrophylla) in South America: Historic range at top, 2008 range at bottom.

Historic and 2008 range of big-leaf mahogany (Swietenia macrophylla) in South America (maps from Wikimedia Commons)

Elephants and mahogany are just two of six examples described in the article. Read about more species that evolved under human pressure including cliff swallows in Nebraska that have shorter wings at Shrinking trees and tuskless elephants: the strange ways species are adapting to humans.

So many things have changed because of us.

Wild Bird Flu Outbreak in PA & Delaware

Snow geese landing in a field in Central PA, Jan 2023 (photo by fishhawk via Flickr Creative Commons license)

3 January 2025

On New Year’s Day Paul Nale reported hundreds of dead and dying snow geese in Northampton County on the PA Birders Facebook group.

screenshot of PA Birders Facebook post by Paul Nale on 1 Jan 2025

There were over 100 dead and dying snow geese at the limestone quarry in Nazareth PA [Northampton County] this afternoon. We have a possible avian influenza outbreak on our hands. I have contacted the PA Game Commission.

PA Birders Facebook Post, 1 January 2025 by Paul Nale

Yesterday the PA Game Commission said there were also dead snow geese at Upper Macungie Township in Lehigh County, both with a “strong suspicion of avian influenza.”

UPDATE as of 8:50 AM 1/2/25: The PA Game Commission has had specialists in the quarry at Nazareth to collect the dead snow geese. There are reportedly hundreds now. There are too many to even try to collect them all. The birds are reportedly on their way to or at the lab for autopsy. In my post last evening, I used the word POSSIBLE … This morning the staffer calling me used the words “strong suspicion of avian influenza.” Tests will confirm or reject that hypothesis.

PA Birders Facebook Post, 2 January 2025 by Paul Nale

The Pennsylvania outbreak follows quickly on the heels of a similar outbreak in Delaware just five days earlier.

On 27 December dead and dying snow geese were discovered at Prime Hook and other sites in Surrey County, DE. On 28 December the State of Delaware confirmed avian influenza and warned poultry farmers and the public to take precautions.

It is not surprising that bird flu is spreading in the wild from state to state. Birds fly and Prime Hook, Delaware is only 130 miles from Nazareth, PA, well within the snow goose range of up to a thousand miles per day in migration.

Meanwhile, the state of Pennsylvania urges everyone to take these precautions:

from PA Press Release, 2 Jan 2025, INFLUENZA SUSPECTED IN SNOW GOOSE MORTALITIES

  • Those encountering sick or dead wild birds can report them to the Pennsylvania Game Commission by calling 1-833-PGC-WILD (1-833-742-9453), by emailing pgc-wildlifehealth@pa.gov or by using the online Wildlife Health Survey tool.
  • Any sick or dead domestic birds should be reported to Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture at 717-772-2852. If you have had contact with sick or dead birds and are not feeling well, contact your primary care physician or the Pennsylvania Department of Health at 877-724-3258.
  • Always observe wildlife from a safe distance. Avoid contacting surfaces that may be contaminated with feces from wild or domestic birds. Do not handle wildlife unless you are hunting, trapping, or otherwise authorized to do so.
  • Waterfowl hunters are encouraged to continue participating in the remaining season, but should take precautions while handling and dressing birds. These include wearing nitrile gloves, protective eye wear, and a mask. Following any hunt make a point to practice good hygiene, including washing hands and any clothing used in the process of dressing game that may contain blood or feces. Finally, never handle wildlife that is sick or displaying signs of sickness. Instead, report it to the Game Commission.

At this moment bird flu can only be caught by human contact with infected birds or animals but we should take care not catch it. Why? Because the more people who catch it, the more likely it will mutate within humans to something we can spread directly to each other. When that happens, all bets are off. Read more about bird flu transmission and humans at the BBC.

p.s. This map of recent HPAI (highly pathogenic avian influenza) outbreaks in the wild is current to 18 Dec 2024. It is maintained by USDA but does not yet include this week’s news from PA and Delaware which I’ve added in pink. Watch here for a USDA update this month!

States detecting HPAI (bird flu) in wild birds in last 30 days as of 18 Dec 2024 (map from USDA) — updated in pink with PA & DE outbreaks 27 Dec to 1 Jan 2025

Sinkholes Top the News

Sinkhole in Germany (photo from Wikimedia)

10 December 2024

A sinkhole topped the news in western Pennsylvania last week when a 64 year old grandmother, Elizabeth Pollard, fell into one after sunset in Unity Twp, Westmoreland County, located 40 miles from Pittsburgh.

Ms. Pollard was last seen Monday [2 December at 5pm] while searching for her cat, Pepper, outside Monday’s Union Restaurant. She fell through the sinkhole that had “just enough dirt” for a roof system and grass to grow, Trooper Limani said.  

Post-Gazette: Crews find body of missing Westmoreland County grandmother at bottom of sinkhole

It took four days to find her body 30 feet down in the Marguerite mine whose roof and pillars are slowly collapsing after it was abandoned in 1950. It’s horrifying to think that when she stepped on a patch of grass a hole opened up and swallowed her. [More news at end.]

Meanwhile an ever-growing sinkhole began in late November in South Wales (news here) and on 4 December the Guardian ran a photo essay of sinkholes around the world.

So I began to wonder: What causes sinkholes? Where are they likely? and Why are they round? My answers will be briefly paraphrased from PA DEP, Wikipedia and USGS.


What causes sinkholes?

Sinkholes are all about water. Water drains rapidly into the ground or runs underground and dissolves the subsurface, creating a void. For a while the surface remains intact, then it collapses into the void.

Sinkhole development diagram from USGS (tiny tree added to show dramatic effect on surface objects)

Most sinkholes are caused by karst processes – the chemical dissolution of carbonate rocks such as limestone or gypsum.

Human activity can cause sinkholes, too, including:

  • Groundwater pumping
  • Digging, drilling or removing soil
  • Water main breaks and intense concentrations of storm water
  • Dams large and small
  • Mining
  • Heavy loads on the surface.

Where are sinkholes likely?

Naturally occurring: According to American Geosciences, the most sinkhole-prone states are Florida, Texas, Alabama, Missouri, Kentucky, Tennessee, and Pennsylvania because these have naturally occurring karst beneath the surface. Three kinds of karst are shown on this USGS map.

Natural sinkhole-prone areas, map from USGS

Caused by mines: Mine subsidence is a big problem for abandoned mines in Pennsylvania. As the Post-Gazette points out, sinkholes form when the old mine roof is less than 100 feet below the surface. Nowadays a coal seam just 20 feet below the surface would be strip-mined, not deep mined.

The PA DEP Mine Subsidence Insurance Risk Map shows coal and mine locations. If you live in an undermined area (gray on map), PA DEP says you should get Mine Subsidence Insurance. See the full map here at PA DEP where you can zoom in to your address and get info about insurance. Homeowners Insurance usually does *not* cover mine subsidence so be sure to check PA DEP’s Frequently Asked Questions for important information.

screenshot of PA DEP Mine Subsidence Insurance Risk Map

Why are sinkholes round?

Wikipedia says sinkholes are usually circular. Gizmodo explains why in “Ask a geologist.”

When a void occurs in sediment that has a certain amount of cohesion (‘stickiness’ among sediment grains), the most stable configuration of the roof of the void is a dome, like the dome of the U.S. Capitol building. If that dome collapses, the vertical sides may remain upright, and the open hole will be circular.

Gizmodo: Why are sinkholes round?

Learn more about the sinkhole tragedy in western PA at:

Learn the warning signs of sinkholes at the 7 Most Common Signs of Sinkholes.

Seen This Week: Sun and Unexpected Carbon

Early morning sun and fog at Duck Hollow, 25 November 2024 (photo by Kate St. John)

7 December 2024

This week the city received a light dusting of snow but the ground was not as beautiful as the sky. Two examples: Fog and sun at Duck Hollow before Thanksgiving, and a very red sunrise on 4 December.

Sunrise in Pittsburgh, 4 December 2024 (photo by Kate St. John)

What is this? An arrangement of black carbon.

Faulty oven creates black carbon, November 2024 (photo by Kate St. John)

These were the unexpected result of a faulty oven thermostat that carbonized the Thanksgiving biscuits. Fortunately that carbon is only skin deep. My niece cut off the bottoms. The tops were yummy.

Identify Bird Photos With Merlin

Great blue heron at Cuyahoga Valley National Park, 17 March 2021 (photo by Karyn Delaney)

3 December 2024

Did you know you can identify bird photos on your cellphone? Merlin Bird ID’s Photo ID function was updated last month with thousands of images from Macaulay Library, the home of eBird checklist photos, providing more real life photos of birds in context.

Here’s how it works: If you want to identify the photo above, by Karyn Delaney, open the Merlin app (download here) and choose Photo ID as shown in the screenshots below.

Choose a photo on your phone or in your photo library. Make it fill the box.

Merlin wants to know when and were you saw the bird because it helps with bird ID.

Quick results! Plus lots of information about the bird.


I found out about the Photo ID upgrade when the Macaulay Library thanked me for contributing photos to eBird and said they used 3 of them. Since I rarely take pictures of birds I have almost no photos in my eBird checklists. I can almost guess which ones they picked: Two peregrine photos and one mockingbird.

Peregrine at Sewickley Bridge, 28 February 2022 (photo by Kate St. John)
Peregrine at Graff Bridge, Kittanning, 7 Jun 2018 (photo by Kate St. John)
Northern mockingbird missing its tail, Phipps Conservatory front lawn, 27 March 2017 (photo by Kate St. John)

Try out the Merlin app and see how it works.

Add photos to your eBird checklists and contribute to bird identification.

Read more about the Photo ID upgrade here at eBird news.

This Can’t Be Good for Our Eagles

Bald eagle with nestling, 23 March 2019 (screenshot from Bald Eagles in Western PA – Audubon Facebook page)

26 November 2024

On 14 November The Allegheny Front described oil pollution on the Monongahela River that’s been happening for more than two years. Monitored by Three Rivers Waterkeeper since May 2022, an oil sheen sometimes covers the water from bank to bank for three miles, all the way to McKeesport. This can’t be good for our bald eagles who nest along on the Mon and eat fish from its water.

In October 2023 Three Rivers Waterkeeper posted photos of the oil sheen on Instagram.

“These are pretty serious sheens,” said Captain Evan Clark, a boat captain for Three Rivers Waterkeeper. “When I’m boating around up there, my boat is running through a heavy rainbow sheen that can extend from one bank of the river to the other, literally for miles.”

In August 2022, an EPA inspector reported oil discharge from the plant’s outfall, or drainage pipe, and found “substantial rainbow sheening could be seen for approximately 3 miles downstream.”(*)

The Allegheny FRONT: Group wants stricter permit for U.S. Steel to stop oily releases into Mon River

Last year the Pennsylvania Dept of Environmental Protection (DEP) determined the oil was coming from a USS Irvin Works outfall and “issued a compliance order requiring U.S. Steel to deploy absorbent booms, investigate the cause of the releases and implement a plan to fix any problems.” — The Allegheny Front 

But a year later the problem has not been addressed and it happened again last month. DEP has proposed setting a water pollution permit level on that outfall. Three Rivers Waterkeeper wants real-time monitoring on it.

Meanwhile, oil-covered water cannot be good for our bald eagles who touch the water’s surface and eat fish and waterfowl captured in or on the water.

Bald eagle about to catch a fish (photo from Wikimedia Commons)

During an oil sheen episode the pair that nests at USS Irvin Works cannot hunt the Mon for three miles downstream of their nest without being exposed to the oil. This is a lot of territory to avoid with hungry chicks in the nest.

screenshot from USS Irvin Works Eaglecam via PixCams on YouTube, 5 April 2022

Employees at USS Irvin Works are so proud of their bald eagle pair that the company installed an eaglecam to watch them at the nest. Surely USS Irvin Works will clean up this outfall to protect everyone who uses the Mon including their favorite eagles.

Read more about the issue here at The Allegheny Front …

… and WTAE’s 26 November report: Mon River oil sheens: Environmentalists urge stricter enforcement on US Steel.